joabos's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[stick figure ? collection]

shhhiiiiiiiiit

Just because he's a beginner flash animator doesn't mean you should cut him any slack. That's how a person improves. With criticism.

But yeah, this was pretty bad. You just kept resizing the things and the only actual drawings were just a stickfigure and a badly drawn tile. You also put some music on there, i see. It didn't match the animation and served only as to fulfill the lack of voices.

If at least your stickfigure was like the icon, and was actually animated, it would be much better, and although still not very good, i'd still vote it higher.

Also, I think the guy underneath me is joking. We do that a lot on NG, i think you already know.

...And it seems you tell people who didn't like it that it was meant to be crappy, but then the guy below me got "THE STUFF YOU WANT TO HEAR" (So you don't want any criticism... Stupid kid, then you can't even be called an artist of any kind) and "so that that, ppl who hate my flash skills" and also "as long as there's still one or two ppl out there who like my flash animations, ill keep making them FOREVER."

Also, I saw your other flash...It was better, but why make a flash that's "supposed to be crappy"? At least make it 'Jerry Jacksons' crappy, not THIS.

wolfdawg125 responds:

u said: "(So you don't want any criticism... Stupid kid, then you can't even be called an artist of any kind)" wow. am i supposed to WANT criticism? btw, so much for "constructive" criticism your not supposed to insult the animator. ("stupid kid") look for a fight somewhere else plz. btw, ur the guy who commented like an asshole on my post. wtf is ur prob? i haven't done anything to u and you go and piss me off. who the hell goes around insulting ppl for no reason anyway? understand the fine line between CONSTRUCTIVE criticism and criticism. u said: "Just because he's a beginner flash animator doesn't mean you should cut him any slack. That's how a person improves. With criticism." add one word to that sentence and i would think it would be a fair review.

["Unblamable" The Movie]

This was good. Real good.

Everything was perfect, I can't even criticize this because of how good it is.

Like they say, "A Kat is fine too."

Kottbullar responds:

^^
Thanks for the review man

[Its a Tank!]

Geniousity.

Very creative, very good effects and editing.

Although Tom kept pushing things that weren't on the way, lol.

[The Shape N' Shape Collab]

Most of them wasn't very well executed.

I'm not going to cite names as you can see which animations had effort put into them, even though they were something as simple as a shape flash, but there was lots of original humor in there. It was worth watching.

ChandlerThompson responds:

Thanks man, I'm glad you liked some of it. You can see how many of the parts were well executed, while some (like mine) were done in five minutes. Nonetheless, thanks for the review!

[Badass Dora!]

Great!

I love the references to the show, and the style of the animation was very smooth, too! overall very nice, but it could have been longer...

[Love Lockdown]

Well, nice.

Sketchy, and has a mildly interesting story. A bit cliché, and it could use more frames between movement. Sometimes you also made some scenes too fast.

I hope you get better, this was a nice beggining flash.

[Planetoid - Chapter 2]

This series is great...

It kept me watching, as it is very interesting, but in this one the end wasn't very clear. The little image ( You know, the one close to "Watch this movie!") is very bad, though. I like the concept of changing the style every chapter.

Fate responds:

Isn't clear...
huh.
I suppose it gets explained...IN THE NEXT ONE :D
but how is it less clear than the first? :P
I thought I'd be getting heaps of complaints about the 'snow place lie comb' thing.
But I'm glad you enjoyed it.
and thanks for the ongoing support (^^)

[Planetoid - Original]

Great!

It was very good, but i think it could use less real images (The planet, the tree, the alien's corpse... wasn't it supposed to be red anyway?)

But there are things that were good like that, such as the fire when the rocketship leaves, the rocketship itself, the asteroids...
Overall, it was pretty nice. I've said it before and i'll say it again: You are a rising legend, NightBreaker.

Fate responds:

Alien's corpse...?
maybe you mis-interpretted that.
I know there's a few people that have.

Baha, I don't think there was a shot of the rocketship that didn't go through three different programs to get it to look like that.
And I doubt the legend part.

[Teh Random Field 2]

everybody keeps calling it bad...

it was good actually, the lip sync was awesome for a practice.

[don't watch this]

genious, except...NOT

it's badly drawn, but that's what makes it authentic. very good and fun to watch, because there is lots of imagination in it. a sequel would be good.